As of 2024, the Ephs have compiled a 140-46 record in Little Three competition, winning 63 titles. The Ephs have finished second 17 times and third 14 times. 

Longest win streak: 29, from 1988 through 2016.

Year	Record	Finish
1924	2-0	1
1925	2-0	1
1926	1-1	2
1927*	0-1	2
1928*	1-0	1
1929*	1-0	1
1930	0-2	3
1931	0-2	3
1932	0-2	3
1933	2-0	1
1934	1-1	2
1935	2-0	1
1936	0-2	3
1937	2-0	1
1938	0-2	3
1939	2-0	1
1940	0-2	3
1941	2-0	1
1942	2-0	1
1943	WWII - no competition
1944	"
1945	"
1946	2-0	1
1947	2-0	1
1948	2-0	1
1949	2-0	1
1950	1-1	2
1951	1-1	2
1952	1-1	2
1953	1-1	2
1954	0-2	3
1955	1-1	2
1956	0-2	3
1957	0-2	3
1958	1-1	2
1959	1-1	2
1960	1-1	2
1961	1-1	2
1962	1-1	2
1963	0-2	3
1964	0-2	3
1965	1-1	2
1966	0-2	3
1967	2-0	1
1968	2-0	1
1969	0-2	3
1970	2-0	1
1971	2-0	1
1972	2-0	1
1973	2-0	1
1974	2-0	1
1975	2-0	1
1976	2-0	1
1977	2-0	1
1978	2-0	1
1979	2-0	1
1980	2-0	1
1981	2-0	1
1982	2-0	1
1983	2-0	1
1984	1-1	2
1985	2-0	1
1986	2-0	1
1987	0-2	3
1988	2-0	1
1989	2-0	1
1990	2-0	1
1991	2-0	1
1992	2-0	1
1993	2-0	1
1994	2-0	1
1995	2-0	1
1996	2-0	1
1997	2-0	1
1998	2-0	1
1999	2-0	1
2000	2-0	1
2001	2-0	1
2002	2-0	1
2003	2-0	1
2004	2-0	1
2005	2-0	1
2006	2-0	1
2007	2-0	1
2008	2-0	1
2009	2-0	1
2010	2-0	1
2011	2-0	1
2012	2-0	1
2013	2-0	1
2014	2-0	1
2015	2-0	1
2016	2-0	1
2017	1-1	2
2018	1-1	2
2019	2-0	1
2021	2-0	1
2022	2-0	1
2023	2-0	1
2024	1-1	2

*Amherst did not participate