Williams has played Colby since 2000.

Williams leads the all-time series 26-3-1 through 2024.

Year	Winner	Location (W/C)	Score	Tournament
2024	Colby	W	2-1 1OT	NESCAC Quarterfinals
2024	Williams	C	1-0
2023	Williams	W	4-0
2022	Williams	C	2-1
2021	Williams	W	3-0
2020	No contest due to pandemic
2019	Williams	C	1-0
2018	Williams	W	3-1	NESCAC Quarterfinals
2018	Williams	W	1-0
2017	Williams	C	3-0
2016	Williams	W	1-0
2015	Williams	C	8-0
2014	Williams	W	1-0	NESCAC Quarterfinals
2014	Williams	W	2-0
2013	Williams	C	2-1
2012	Williams	C	2-1
2011	Williams	W	2-1
2010	Williams	W	4-0
2009	Williams	W	4-0	NESCAC Quarterfinals
2009	Williams	C	3-0
2008	Williams	W	4-0	NESCAC Quarterfinals
2008	Williams	C	1-0
2007	Williams	W	5-1
2006	Colby	W	2-1	NESCAC Tournament
2006	Tie	N	2-2
2005	Williams	W	1-0
2004	Colby	C	1-0
2003	Williams	W	4-0
2002	Williams	C	3-0
2001	Williams	W	2-1, 2 OT
2000	Williams	C	1-0