Williams has played Wesleyan since 1978.

Williams leads the series 38-4-2 through 2018.
Year  Winner
Location
(W/Wes)
Score
Tournament
2018 Williams W 2-1  
2017 Williams Wes 1-0  
2016 Williams W 6-0  
2015 Williams Wes 1-0 2OT  
2014 Williams W 4-0  
2013 Williams W 3-1  
2013 Williams Wes 1-0 OT  
2012 Williams W 2-1 NESCAC Semis
2012 Williams W 3-1  
2011 Williams Wes 2-0  
2010 Williams W 4-1 NESCAC Quarters
2010 Tie Wes 2-2  
2009 Williams W 5-0  
2008 Williams W 3-0  
2007 Williams Wes.  1-0  
2006 Williams W 5-1  
2005 Williams Wes. 2-1  
2004 Williams W 4-0  
2003 Williams Wes.  5-0  
2002 Williams W 5-0  
2001 Williams Wes.  3-2  
2000 Williams W 4-1  
1999 Williams Wes. 4-1  
1998 Williams W 3-0  
1997 Williams Wes.  2-1  
1996 Williams W 1-0  
1995 Williams Wes. 3-2  
1994 Williams W 2-1  
1993 Williams Wes. 2-0  
1992 Williams W 2-1  
1991 Williams Wes. 2-1  
1990 Williams W 10-0  
1989 Williams Wes. 1-0  
1988 Williams W 1-0  
1987 Williams Wes. 3-0  
1986 Williams W 1-0  
1985 Tie Wes. 4-4  
1984 Williams W 2-0  
1983 Williams Wes. 1-0  
1982 Wesleyan Wes. 1-0  
1981 Wesleyan W 2-0  
1980 Wesleyan Wes. 2-0  
1979 Wesleyan W 5-4  
1978 Williams Wes. 2-1