Skip To Main Content
Skip To Main Content

Williams College

Matt Bott reacts after scoring a touchdown against Amherst, Nov. 14, 2026
Maya Singh
Matt Bott celebrates after scoring the Ephs' touchdown.

Ephs End Up on Wrong End of Defensive Struggle Against Amherst

Homecoming did not go Williams’ way in the 16-7 loss to the Mammoths

11/14/2026 5:05:00 PM

Box Score

WILLIAMSTOWN, Mass. — The Biggest Little Game in America rarely disappoints, and the 140th meeting between Williams College and Amherst College was no exception, unless you were an Eph fan. With the Mammoths nursing a 10-7 lead late in the fourth quarter, Amherst quarterback Marek Hill lofted a high pass to the corner of the end zone where senior cornerback Holden Gering and receiver Christian Moore gathered themselves as the ball floated toward them, with the weight of the rivalry matchup on the line.

Gering rose up first and got his hands on the football, before tumbling to the turf in a wrestling match with Moore. The two players fought for possession as they lay in the end zone, and the referees signaled that the result of the play was a touchdown, giving the Mammoths a 16-7 lead with 3:36 left to play. Amherst would hold on from there, escaping Farley-Lamb Field with a victory in front of an overflow crowd.

For the Ephs, the Homecoming defeat left them 5-4 for the third consecutive season. And thanks to Wesleyan's 27-20 win at Trinity this afternoon, Amherst earned a share of the NESCAC title with those two schools, all of whom finished at 8-1. One of those teams will also qualify for the NCAA playoffs for the first time in the history of the NESCAC.

Saturday's matchup was powered primarily by defense. Both teams finished over 70 yards below their season averages for total yardage, and the Ephs held the Mammoths to just 2.5 yards per rush, on 36 carries.

"Those five interior guys today were outstanding," Williams Head Coach Mark Raymond said. "I thought they did a great job of tackling and being physical against the run."

The first five possessions of the game ended with punts, but toward the end of the quarter, the Mammoths drove into Williams territory, with Hill finding his receiver, Max Alexander, over the middle on a 4th-and-8 to keep the drive alive. Several plays later, running back Zach Curtin charged up the middle for a 7-yard touchdown for a 7-0 lead with 13:27 to go in the first half.

In response, the Ephs put together their best drive of the day. A 13-yard end-around from senior Brady Stahelski set the tone, and senior quarterback Drew Renzella settled in, picking up gains with both his arm and his legs, driving deep into Amherst territory. On the thirteenth play of the drive, junior running back Matt Bott eluded a defender at the line of scrimmage and darted in for a three-yard touchdown, tying the game at 7-7 with five minutes to go. Neither team would score again in the half.

Amherst gained the advantage on its second drive of the second half as Hill found Moore on a 42-yard deep strike down the left sideline. The big gain set up a 29-yard field goal from Hudson Fulcher-Melendy, giving the Mammoths a 10-7 lead late in the third quarter.

The Ephs' following drive looked promising as Stahelski got loose on another big end-around play, this time for 17 yards, and steady runs by first-year Aidan Clark pushed Williams inside the Amherst 40. Penalties stymied the momentum, however, and Amherst regained possession after a turnover on downs early in the fourth quarter.

The Mammoths' next drive moved inside the red zone as Hill spread the ball around. On 1st-and-goal from the Williams 8, Hill kept the ball on a designed quarterback keeper, surging toward the end zone. He was met inside the 5, however, by junior linebacker Luke Mangini, who stripped the ball from the Mammoths' quarterback and recovered it all in one motion. Mangini's play came as part of a huge day for the linebacker, who led the Ephs with 10 tackles with a sack and another going for a loss.

"Just a great play from a really outstanding player," Raymond said. "That gave us a chance."

When the Ephs were unable to get a first down and were forced to punt, the Mammoths had great field position at the Williams 45. Hill found Alexander for a 5-yard gain over the middle on a key 4th-and-2, and on a 3rd-and-8, Alexander made a toe-dragging, one-handed catch along the sideline to pick up a huge first down at the 16. He would finish with nine catches for 78 yards, leading all receivers on the day. 

Three plays later, Moore and Gering went up for the jump ball in the end zone, and the refs awarded the touchdown to Amherst, giving the Mammoths a 16-7 lead after a missed extra point.

Renzella and the Ephs wouldn't relent, and went to work one final time with Renzella running the hurry-up offense effectively, finding juniors Zach Falls and Jimmy Montesano for several chunk pass plays to move quickly into the red zone. But on 4th-and-4 from the 15, Renzella's pass was intercepted by Carson Skotak, who returned the ball down the right sideline and into Williams territory, sealing the outcome.

Amherst finished the day with 264 total yards to Williams' 192 with Hill completing 17-of-27 passes for 173 yards. Renzella connected on half of his throws (14-of-28) for 99 yards. Falls caught seven of the completions for 47 yards.

Print Friendly Version